AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsToday’s news, without the noise.
Worldwide Column · 17250 Dallas Pkwy, Dallas, TX 75248

NSW inquest hears birth keeper advised rest after urgent hospital referral

An inquest into four babies’ deaths has heard that a mother was advised to return home and rest after being urged to seek emergency hospital care.

By Sergio Nunez ·

Illustration for: NSW inquest hears birth keeper advised rest after urgent hospital referral
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A pregnant woman whose baby later died was advised by a self-described birth keeper to return home and rest despite urgent medical advice to attend an emergency department, a New South Wales inquest has heard. The evidence was presented as proceedings opened at Lismore local court on Monday, November 16.

The inquest concerns four babies who died following free births or home births in the northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024. Sita Tara Kali was involved in caring for two of them. None of the four babies’ families attended the opening. The court will consider whether the care provided was reasonable, including whether support from an unregistered worker was appropriate before, during and after birth.

The court heard that the mother of Baby R distrusted hospitals and placed her trust in Kali. She believed giving birth at home would strengthen her connection with her baby. In a statement to police, the mother described feeling threatened by her hospital experiences.

An ultrasound at 43 weeks showed that Baby R was extremely compromised. The inquest heard that the mother received urgent obstetric advice to go to an emergency department and was strongly advised against giving birth at home. She then contacted Kali, who described the mother in her police statement as upset and anxious. Kali said she advised her to go home, rest, calm herself and consider what she wanted to do.

Baby R was born outdoors into his father’s hands at 9.51am, with two doulas present, neither of whom had medical training. He appeared white and never latched on to feed. An ambulance was called about 14 hours after the birth, while his placenta and umbilical cord remained attached. He died at 12.22am while being taken to a waiting helicopter.

The cause of death remained unascertained. An expert neonatologist nevertheless suggested that Baby R died from hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy resulting from severe post-maturity, having been born at 43 weeks.

Midwifery academic Prof Hannah Dahlen, who has attended thousands of births, told the court she would have monitored the baby closely. She explained that midwives combine clinical experience with theoretical knowledge, enabling them to interpret symptoms, recognise problems and make decisions about care.

Counsel assisting Ragni Mathur told the inquest that women’s decisions to pursue unregulated free birthing reflected several factors. These included traumatic or coercive experiences, fragmented care, distrust of clinicians, shortages of clinicians and services in regional NSW, child protection notifications and regulatory actions against New Lives.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Worldwide Column in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Worldwide Column in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.