AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsToday’s news, without the noise.
Worldwide Column · 17250 Dallas Pkwy, Dallas, TX 75248

Government Faces Criticism Over Unknown Costs for Maternity Unit Repairs

Ministers are under fire for not knowing the cost of repairing unsafe NHS maternity units, with critics warning that aging infrastructure poses serious risks to mothers and babies.

By Francesca Youssef ·

Illustration for: Government Faces Criticism Over Unknown Costs for Maternity Unit Repairs
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Government ministers have faced sharp criticism for admitting they do not know the full cost of repairing aging NHS maternity units. The Liberal Democrats described the situation as gambling with the safety of mothers and babies. This controversy stems from recent parliamentary responses indicating a lack of clear financial planning for infrastructure upgrades.

Karin Smyth, the NHS minister at the Department of Health and Social Care, stated that the department could not provide a specific figure for upgrading units. NHS England has identified facilities that require significant repair or replacement soon. Some of these units are running a serious risk of imminent breakdown according to internal assessments.

Helen Morgan, the Liberal Democrats' health spokesperson, highlighted the severity of the issue. She noted that NHS England has clearly warned about dozens of units falling apart. Morgan argued that it is appalling that the government lacks a cost estimate for making these units fit for purpose despite the warnings.

NHS England reported last year that 43% of maternity and neonatal units in England failed to meet basic safety standards due to poor infrastructure. These problems have hampered clinical care delivery thousands of times every year. The Care Quality Commission has also expressed concern that lack of space and aging facilities present serious safety risks.

Specific examples of deteriorating conditions have emerged from recent reports. At Musgrove Park hospital in Taunton, a review found leaking roofs and poor temperature control. The antenatal ward is currently being propped up by metal poles due to structural disrepair. Hospital bosses acknowledged the unit is old, outdated, and cramped, though they rated the staff care as good.

At Stepping Hill hospital in Stockport, a father described holding up a loose ceiling light for an hour during his wife's labor. The light narrowly missed a midwife before falling. The hospital's chief executive believes the 121-year-old building needs 400 million pounds to ensure safety for patients and staff. She described the hospital as being in a death spiral due to constant leaks and decay.

NHS England data shows that in the last three years, there were 14,519 formally reported instances where poor physical conditions interrupted clinical services. Issues such as power outages and faulty nurse call systems put additional pressure on stretched staff. These problems can lead directly to delays in procedures like planned caesarean sections.

St Helier hospital in south London is currently relocating its maternity services because of urgently needed repairs. The trust's chief executive explained that significant work cannot be done while maintaining a safe environment for babies and families in the existing building. This move highlights the urgent nature of infrastructure failures across the network.

The financial context of these repairs is complicated by recent budget decisions. Ministers cut 1 billion pounds from the NHS capital budget over the next four years to help boost defense spending. This reduction comes as the cost of eradicating the maintenance backlog has risen to 17.3 billion pounds according to official figures.

The Department of Health and Social Care blamed previous administrations for leaving the physical fabric of the NHS to crumble. A spokesperson said the government has invested 271 million pounds since April 2025 into critical safety schemes. They also announced more than 1.5 billion pounds for broader building improvements, aiming to reach a record capital budget of 15 billion pounds by 2029-30.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Worldwide Column in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Worldwide Column in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.