ICC closes US-focused Afghanistan probe as sanctions pressure mounts
The International Criminal Court has closed its investigation into alleged US war crimes in Afghanistan, a move intended to ease diplomatic tensions while the probe into the Taliban continues under a new designation.
By Ananya Wright ·

Judges at the International Criminal Court have ordered the closure of the specific portion of the Afghanistan investigation that covered alleged war crimes by United States forces. This decision marks a significant shift in the court's long-standing inquiry, which has been a source of tension between The Hague and Washington for years.
The move effectively addresses one of the primary objections held by the US government regarding its relationship with the court. For a decade, Washington has resisted the ICC's jurisdiction, a stance that contributed to the imposition of sanctions on the institution and its officials. By ending the probe into US military conduct, the court may be signaling an effort to ease these diplomatic frictions.
The origins of the Afghanistan situation at the ICC date back to November 2017. At that time, then-prosecutor Fatou Bensouda requested authorization to investigate crimes committed since 2003 by various parties, including Afghan and US forces, the Taliban, and the Islamic State-Khorasan Province. A pre-trial chamber initially rejected this request in 2019, but an appeals chamber reversed that decision in March 2020, allowing the investigation to proceed.
Following the 2020 authorization, the US government sanctioned Bensouda and several members of the appeals chamber. They were cited for attempting to subject American nationals to the court's jurisdiction. In a subsequent development, six states including France, Spain, and Chile referred new allegations of crimes against women and girls committed since the Taliban returned to power in August 2021. Prosecutors were asked to integrate these claims into the existing framework.
The latest ruling, dated 12 November, specifically closes the strand of the probe dealing with US forces and IS-K. However, the inquiry into the Taliban remains active. This part of the investigation is now designated as Afghanistan II, a title adopted by judges on 20 October. The judges argued that the post-2021 conduct by the Taliban is materially different from the earlier armed conflict, warranting a separate legal track.
Records related to the Taliban, including four arrest warrants, have been transferred to the new Afghanistan II situation. This procedural split follows earlier reporting that judges had instructed prosecutors to separate the two distinct phases of the conflict. The Office of the Prosecutor has appealed the closure decision, as well as previous orders regarding the separation of the investigations. Those appeals are currently pending before the appeals chamber.
Diplomatic efforts to resolve the standoff between the court and the US have intensified. In December, diplomats at the annual Assembly of States Parties meeting reported that the Trump administration had pressed the court to drop its Afghanistan and Palestine investigations as a condition for lifting sanctions. The US also sought amendments to the Rome Statute to protect nationals from non-member states like the US and Israel.
Last week, Dutch Foreign Minister Tom Berendsen indicated that discussions with Washington were ongoing, though a ministry spokesperson clarified that there were no direct negotiations on amending the treaty. The government is exploring dialogue with non-member states to ensure the court's independence and effectiveness. Member states are scheduled to convene in The Hague from 30 November to 7 December to continue these deliberations.
Washington imposed institutional sanctions on the ICC on 9 October, granting a six-month grace period for the court to address US demands. These measures could restrict the court's ability to transact in US dollars, potentially impacting its operations. The pre-trial chamber's decision to split the investigation in July came shortly after US Secretary of State Marco Rubio threatened to dismantle the court, citing its 2020 authorization of the Afghanistan probe.
Since February 2025, the US has targeted court officials with financial and visa sanctions. This includes former prosecutor Karim Khan, who was removed in July following a misconduct probe, and nine judges. Three of these judges, including Kimberly Prost, Solomy Bossa, and Luz Ibanez, were part of the 2020 appeals chamber that authorized the investigation. The sanctions were imposed despite Khan's 2021 decision to deprioritize the probe of US and CIA personnel to focus on the Taliban and IS-K.






