AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsToday’s news, without the noise.
Worldwide Column · 17250 Dallas Pkwy, Dallas, TX 75248

England weighs new appeal routes in special needs education reform

The UK government is considering two new independent appeal routes for special needs disputes to address criticism that school-led reviews are inadequate.

By Ananya Wright ·

Illustration for: England weighs new appeal routes in special needs education reform
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Families of children with special educational needs in England may soon have new options for appealing decisions regarding their child's support. The government is currently considering significant changes to the appeals process as part of its broader overhaul of special needs education.

These potential concessions come after sustained criticism from parents' groups and campaigners. They argued that the proposed reforms risked weakening legal protections by limiting the ability of families to take cases to a high court tribunal. The goal of the new avenues is to provide a forum for dissatisfaction with the provision offered by schools.

Education Secretary Lucy Powell addressed concerns raised by members of parliament by suggesting that adjustments to the appeals mechanism are a priority. She indicated that ensuring proper channels for accountability is a key part of the current review, urging stakeholders to wait for the final details.

The proposed changes stem from a white paper published in February. This document outlines a shift away from education, health and care plans, known as EHCPs, toward individual support plans, or ISPs. Under the new system, schools would manage these support tiers. Previously, parents could appeal disputes over EHCPs to an independent first-tier tribunal, but the reforms initially suggested that schools would handle complaints about ISPs, a move that drew sharp criticism.

Policymakers began exploring alternative routes after the white paper was released under former Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson. Two independent options are now under active consideration to replace the limited school-led process.

One option involves appealing to the local government and social care ombudsman. This body already investigates complaints against local authorities regarding special needs provision and school transport. The alternative route would see parents appeal to an independent review panel, similar to those used for school exclusions. Such panels consist of a clerk and up to five experts with no direct link to the school involved and have the power to overturn decisions.

Jane Harris, chief executive of the charity Speech and Language UK, emphasized the need for independence. She stated that schools should not be expected to judge their own performance. Harris argued that the body hearing appeals must have the right expertise and that its decisions must be legally meaningful to ensure timely action for children.

Madeleine Cassidy, chief executive of the charity Ipsea, described the government's consideration of alternatives as encouraging. Cassidy noted that the plan to reduce the powers of the current tribunal has been a major concern. She called for extending the ombudsman's remit to schools but warned that stronger complaint mechanisms must not compromise robust legal rights.

A Department for Education spokesperson said the government is reviewing all input from consultation events. The department stated it is investing in schools to improve inclusion and create a system where children receive appropriate support locally without the need for conflict. The bill and the government's response to the consultation are not expected until early next year.

The urgency of the issue is highlighted by recent statistics. The average waiting time for a final oral hearing at the current tribunal is now over 18 months, meaning a new appeal could wait until May 2028. The tribunal is also facing record pressure, with 8,800 appeals lodged in the three months leading up to June. The total backlog has risen to 18,000 cases, a 31 percent increase since 2025.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Worldwide Column in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Worldwide Column in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.