AdvertiseDonate
☰ SectionsToday’s news, without the noise.
Worldwide Column · 17250 Dallas Pkwy, Dallas, TX 75248
Local reports · CalMatters

Californians are paying for the oil industry’s risky Plan B: burying carbon dioxide

By Liza Tucker, CalMatters ·

This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.

Guest Commentary written by

Liza Tucker

Liza Tucker is a consumer advocate for Consumer Watchdog.

The United Nations says we’ve blown past the deadline for limiting worldwide global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (or 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial times.

To avoid catastrophe, we’re supposed to use unproven technology at a vast scale to suck carbon dioxide out of the air while slashing emissions — in other words, throw spaghetti against a wall to see what sticks.

One tool gaining attention is carbon capture and storage technology, which draws CO2 from industrial smokestacks and buries it.

The trouble is carbon capture storage, touted by the oil industry, is a bust. And it keeps us handcuffed to climate-destroying fossil fuels.

The better choice is to vastly expand what is proven: Ramp up renewable energy, energy efficiency and electrification, while cutting greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel production and transportation. What’s missing is the political will and the investment to do that.

Today carbon capture storage technology permanently buries less CO2 than a single large power plant can emit in a year, a ProPublica investigation revealed in June. And not one carbon capture storage project has come close to industry claims of up to 95% capture rates.

Yet, under relentless oil industry lobbying, California has gone whole hog on this multibillion-dollar boondoggle — turbocharged by federal tax credits and state incentives — before carbon storage rules are even set.

Last year California lifted a partial moratorium on building compressed CO2 pipelines, which would carry this lethal asphyxiant to burial. The law did not require that an odorant be added to warn residents of a gas leak, nor did it prescribe a stringent buffer zone between communities and the pipelines.

If a cloud of CO2 is released, it can displace oxygen near the ground, suffocating people and stopping vehicles.

That already has happened. In 2020 a CO2 pipeline ruptured in Satartia, Miss., sending 45 people to hospitals and causing 200 evacuations. News accounts reported victims shaking, struggling to breathe, falling unconscious and foaming at the mouth.

Now Montezuma Carbon, a company in the San Francisco Bay Area, envisions transporting CO2 from plants and utilities in the region via a 40-mile pipeline, and injecting it into saline aquifers two miles beneath the Montezuma Wetlands and its thriving wildlife. Nearby communities already are galvanized against it.

About 20 miles west of Bakersfield, California Resources Corp., the state’s biggest oil producer, is already injecting compressed carbon dioxide from its cryogenic gas plant into a depleted reservoir. The carbon capture storage project began operating in May. There’s no guarantee that won’t leak upward through the Swiss cheese-like structure of old oil wells.

If the government didn’t prop up the proposed carbon capture projects, they would collapse, as California Resources has admitted. Such projects “depend on financial and tax incentives established under federal and state laws, regulations and governmental programs to be economically viable,” the company’s 2025 fiscal report stated.

Most of California Resources’s nearly 40,000 wells produce little or no oil, according to an analysis by FracTracker Alliance. California has 1.2 billion barrels of proved oil reserves remaining — roughly 14 years’ worth at the state’s 2025 production rate — the Energy Information Administration reports.

Exploiting new oil reserves is expensive and requires jumping through legal hoops. No wonder California Resources is pushing carbon capture storage as its Plan B — at public expense.

But every dollar spent on carbon capture storage — instead of wind, water and solar — increases CO2, air pollution, energy costs, pipelines and total societal costs, a 2025 Stanford-led study concluded.

The state should instead pull the plug on carbon capture storage and ensure California Resources and other drillers put up the money to plug their wells and clean up their messes.

That way billions of dollars can be redirected to what we know works.

This story was originally published by CalMatters and is republished under its terms.

Get Worldwide Column in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.