Don’t blame the Texas blue wave on ex-CA’ers
By Mohamed Al Elew, CalMatters ·
We wanted to answer if Californians moving to Texas played an outsized role in the blue tsunami of the Lonestar State. At least for flipping the U.S. Senate seat, the answer is a clear no.
More than 364,000 Californians moved to Texas from 2018 to 2023 according to Internal Revenue Service migration data, and we estimate that less than one third of the voting-age population were Democrats before they headed to the Lonestar State based on the latest review of interstate voter roll data. Democrat James Talarico of Texas won the Senate seat by nearly 1.2 million votes against his main opponent, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, a Republican with close ties to President Donald Trump.
Even if we assume that every former Californian was a registered voter in Texas, then about 103,000 of the over 364,000 who moved from California to Texas were likely registered Democrats. And if every single Democrat in this model turned out and voted for Talarico, it would amount to just about 10% of his margin of victory.
Other analyses back this up: About half of the Californians who moved to Arizona or Texas in the past few years said they were conservative, according to a 2023 Stanford University study. And the Public Policy Institute of California found that conservatives in California tended to head to right-leaning states.
In our analysis, every county in Texas shifted between 7 to 70 percentage points in support of Talarico compared to the 2024 presidential election, when Trump, a Republican, handedly carried the state. The five counties with the largest swing toward Democrats had fewer than one California transplant household per 1,000 households. That means that even if every California transplant hadn’t voted, Talarico still would have won.
Overall, the counties with the highest rates of migration from California swung toward Talarico at levels similar to the whole state’s blue tilt toward Talarico compared to 2024. Again, that’s evidence that California transplants aren’t a major reason for Texas voters backing Talarico.
- David Crockett, a political science professor at Trinity University in San Antonio, on residents who moved to Texas: “There is not an unusual or disproportionately Democratic skew.”
CalMatters Ideas Festival: 2027 Ideas Festival will expand to Los Angeles, Sacramento and San Francisco. One full day of candid conversations in each, with the leaders, innovators and changemakers shaping California’s future. Learn more.
Other Stories You Should Know
Mixed messages on tax measures
The Associated Press officially said that California voters on Friday approved Proposition 42, which bans new wealth taxes by barring taxes on personal property, business interests and financial investments. In combination with the defeat of the proposed billionaire tax, Prop. 40, voters reaffirmed that wealth for the ultrarich is protected.
So does that mean voters are wholly against taxation? Not exactly, write our CalMatters reporters.
The passage of Prop. 42 is somewhat tempered by both the defeat of Prop. 43, which would have made increasing taxes for local public services more difficult, and the success of Prop. 3, which makes permanent a tax on high-income earners to help fund schools.
The mixed outcome, experts say, shows that California voters embrace tax hikes — but only when they can ensure the money is funding tangible services they support.
- Brandon Castillo, a ballot measure strategist in California: “Voters are willing to open up their wallet if they believe it’s for a good cause … and that it’s actually going to that place.”
What’s next for CA’s death penalty?
Local prosecutors in California intend to continue to seek the death penalty, in the wake of Gov. Gavin Newsom commutation of more than 500 death row prisoners last week, reports CalMatters’ Jeanne Kuang.
Nearly 400 of those granted clemency still need approval from the California Supreme Court. But even if the high court approves all of Newsom’s commutations, the state is likely to slowly continue sending defendants to death row.
Jason Anderson, San Bernardino County’s district attorney, is one of several district attorneys who have said they’ll continue to push for death sentences when appropriate. Anderson argued that while he respects differences of opinion on capital punishment, the governor should have considered each case individually.
- Anderson: “You have a law on the books that’s essentially been overridden by one person.”
Anderson has also filed a motion to unseal the criminal records of some of the condemned prisoners from San Bernardino County, so the details of their crimes and what he described as their “recidivist nature” are public. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, which opposes the commutations, has filed similar motions.
And lastly: What do you want public health officials to know?
Have an opinion on what health issues should be prioritized in California? CalMatters is partnering with Your Local Epidemiologist to make the real concerns and questions from Californians heard by public health officials and journalists.
Every Monday, we’ll ask about health topics affecting Californians, and it’ll only take two minutes to answer.
This week, we’re asking about the health impacts of holiday gatherings and the loneliness epidemic. Take the survey.
California Voices
Carbon capture storage is a bust and keeps us handcuffed to climate-destroying fossil fuels — yet California has gone whole hog on this multibillion-dollar boondoggle before carbon storage rules are set, writes Liza Tucker, a consumer advocate for Consumer Watchdog.
Other things worth your time:
Some stories may require a subscription to read.
CA Insurance Department accidentally reveals another judge complained about internal misconduct // CalMatters (free)
Offshore oil rigs could be ‘toppled’ off CA under Trump plan // Los Angeles Times (paywall)
ICE detention deaths: Lawmakers vow action after Chronicle investigation of medical failures // San Francisco Chronicle (gift link)
How a promising Oakland mayor wound up at the center of a bribery scandal // The Guardian (free)
Hollywood’s tax credit push runs into a post-midterm wall // Politico (free)
Silicon Valley tech billionaires see a mistake — and a lesson in Jensen Huang’s ouster, // The Wall Street Journal (gift link)
Surfers scramble to CA hot spot to catch building-size waves // The New York Times (gift link)
This story was originally published by CalMatters and is republished under its terms.
