NSW Coal Mine Bill Faces Corruption Criticism Over Broad Ministerial Powers
Critics warn a Henry VIII clause in a NSW bill to expand the Mount Pleasant coalmine poses a serious corruption risk by granting the resources minister broad law-making powers.
By Francesca Youssef ·

A controversial New South Wales government bill designed to boost coal output at the Mount Pleasant mine in Muswellbrook has drawn sharp criticism from legal experts and opposition politicians. The legislation, set for debate in the state parliament this week, would allow MACH Energy to increase annual production by 32 percent to 16.5 million tonnes. Critics argue that a specific clause in the bill grants the resources minister excessive authority, creating a significant risk for corruption within the state government.
The Minns government introduced the bill last month following a High Court ruling that declared a previous expansion of the mine invalidly approved. Officials stated that the new legislation is essential to prevent the loss of approximately 400 jobs at the site before the holiday season. However, the speed and scope of the legislative response have raised questions among crossbench members and the Greens party about the balance of power being shifted to the executive.
Geoffrey Watson, a barrister and director of the Centre for Public Integrity, issued a legal analysis highlighting Clause 17 of the bill. This provision is commonly known as a Henry VIII clause, a term referencing King Henry VIII’s historical practice of governing by royal proclamation. Watson noted that the clause explicitly places the power to make, repeal, or modify state laws into the hands of a single minister for the benefit of one coal mine owner. He described this concentration of authority as a serious corruption risk, noting that such risks are heightened when legislation is tailored for a single private company.
Watson emphasized that corruption in this context does not necessarily involve direct financial exchanges. Instead, it can refer to undue influence or decisions made outside the public interest. While he attributed no bad faith to the current mining minister, he pointed to historical precedents in the state where such concentrated powers have been scrutinized. He stated that past experience shows not all ministers have acted free from improper motives, making the broad scope of the clause particularly concerning.
Elaine Johnson, director of Johnson Legal and counsel for the Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group, echoed these concerns in a separate legal opinion. She described the corruption risk arising from Clause 17 as very obvious. Johnson explained that the clause gives the resources minister unfettered power to change how any state law applies to the mine. This could potentially affect a wide range of regulations, including those governing noise, dust, and worker safety standards.
The lower house is expected to debate the legislation on Tuesday, with the upper house scheduled to follow later in the week. The government aims to pass the bill during what is likely the final sitting week before the March 2027 election. Political dynamics in the Hunter region add complexity to the debate, as both Labor and Coalition seats face pressure from the One Nation party, which has a strong presence in the area where the mine is located.
One Nation’s New South Wales leader, Mike Newman, criticized the bill as a superficial fix for a deeper problem. In contrast, Dave Layzell, the Coalition resources spokesperson and Member for Upper Hunter, stated that his party would not oppose the legislation in any way. Layzell said the Coalition would rely on advice from the parliament’s legislation review committee, expected to be released Tuesday, regarding the Henry VIII clause. He acknowledged the need to protect jobs and argued that environmental legal delays should not stall projects with community support.
Sue Higginson, the Greens climate spokesperson, described the proposed clause as the broadest she had seen in the current parliament. Her party intends to seek amendments to remove or limit the scope of the clause. Higginson noted that while limited Henry VIII provisions can be necessary, as seen in recent koala park legislation, the current draft places too much power in the hands of a single minister. She suggested this is a corruption risk the Labor government should be familiar with given its own past legislative practices.
A spokesperson for resources minister Courtney Houssos defended the government’s position, stating that the bill’s primary purpose is to protect permanent workers at Mount Pleasant. They emphasized that the bill was presented transparently and that any proposed regulations would be submitted to the Executive Council for approval and published publicly. The spokesperson also noted that such provisions have been routinely used in legislation for decades, including in bills supported by the Greens during this term.
Independent MP Alex Greenwich, who intends to oppose the bill entirely, called the provision dangerously broad and unprecedented. He highlighted a specific procedural concern: because the parliament will not sit for six months after the current sitting week, any regulations issued by the minister during that period could not be disallowed by the legislature. This gap in oversight adds to the urgency surrounding the debate over the bill’s final form.






